One big weapon the police have that they use all the time when it comes to sex crime cases is that it is known as a pretext phone call. This is basically where the alleged victim typically calls the alleged perpetrator on the phone, and the police will tape-record the conversation.
The police, in a calculated move, actively guide the alleged victim with leading questions during the pretext phone call, listen in, and aim to coerce the perpetrator into a confession.
This is a very effective weapon in sex crime-related offenses. If, on the pretext of a phone call, the defendant admits to the crime, this admission can be used against them in future prosecutions. The legal implications of such an admission are significant, as it can be used as direct evidence in court, potentially altering the course of the defendant's life.
This is because most people will not admit that they committed a sex crime unless they did commit the sex crime. See California v. Wismer.
Often, people will not admit that they committed a sex crime on the pretext phone call. However, they will apologize to the victim and act in a way that ensures nobody is harmed.
In other words, if someone tells you Why did you commit this sex crime against me? What were you thinking, and you didn't save it? Your response should be, I don't know what you're talking about; are you crazy? I would never do anything like that.
Instead, we often see that during the pretext phone call, the individual apologizes for their behavior and tries to explain why they did whatever they're being accused of doing.
Legal Defenses to Pretextual Phone Prosecution
One great defense I see is that women often act emotionally and say a lot of crazy things. A person is scared because they feel that the other person is losing their mind and acting crazy, so they apologize or acknowledge something they didn't do to alleviate the other party's concerns.
So, they will be quiet about it and stop going crazy; then, obviously, they will keep away from that particular person. This can be an effective defense if the surrounding circumstances relating to the alleged sex crime are such that the person can defend themselves.
Additionally, the jury will obviously listen to the pretext phone call. They will take that into account with all the other evidence, and they will be the ultimate deciders as to whether or not that pretext phone call means the person is guilty or not. For instance, if the defendant's admission is clear and unambiguous, it can be a compelling piece of evidence for the prosecution.
When it comes to a defense strategy for a pretext phone call, meticulous analysis is key. The call must be carefully analyzed, and the defense attorney, with their expertise and experience, should lead a comprehensive discussion with the defendant about its content, tone, and implications, providing a strong foundation for the defense.
At times, the person's statements in the pretext phone call can align with a defense. When combined with other evidence that supports the narrative in the call, the defendant is in a strong position to challenge the prosecutor's case. This is where the defense attorney's role becomes crucial in mounting a robust defense, offering a potential path to challenge the prosecutor's case.
Getting Legal Advice
Seeking legal advice is crucial in navigating a case involving a pretext phone call. Our law firm is here to help you understand your rights, the implications of the call, and to strategize the best defense for your case.
So, when I have a case where someone's charged with a sex crime and the main piece of evidence is a pretext phone call, or a pretext phone call is evidence in any way in the case, it's crucial to seek legal advice. We discuss what's said, listen to it, and then make decisions about how strong or weak the evidence is and how we will address it.
Are we going to resolve a case because the evidence related to the pretext phone call is substantial, or is the evidence weak? We need to challenge it and present our side of the story, explain why certain things are said in the pretext phone call, and do everything we can to protect your freedom, rights, reputation, and everything necessary to you in your life.
Related Content:
